Attention Customers: Anthony’s Cafe is currently closed at our 2936 Highway Ave. Highland, In. location, We are in the process of moving to Niko’s Restaurant 2934 Highway Ave. Highland, In. Right next door and the move will take place some time in August or September 2015. We will keep you posted via this website on our progress, Sorry for any inconvenience and thank you for your patience and support, have a great summer and see you soon.

Anthony’s Cafe had started as a vision of Tony Fenyves as a blank canvas. Tony wished to bring his talent and restaurant experience and create something really unique in downtown Highland, Indiana.IMG_8604

The Anthony’s Cafe building previously housed the Highland Custard Shop and Porters House, which were two icons of the downtown Highland Area.  As a child, Tony frequently visited the Highland Custard Shop and created some great memories. So when the building became available for sale, Tony knew – that, then and there – was the time to open his cafe.

” The timing was right and the building always and continues to have a magical feel to it.  It has always been a place of fun, laughter and great food.  I have been lucky enough to take it to the next level!” – Tony.

“The previous Highland Custard Shop and Porters House owner, Tom Porter of Highland, was an important element in the transition to Anthony’s Cafe. Tom was very helpful in many ways and to him I will always be grateful. Tom and I are Chefs by trade and share a lot of the same core values in business and community.  I believe Tom is proud to see the cafe to be taken to the next level. Thanks Tom.”

IMG_8639Established in June of 1997, Anthony’s Cafe will soon be celebrating its 16 year anniversary.

Anthony’s Cafe is considered a casual dining dinner restaurant with focus on A+ food, service, atmosphere and music.

The food offered is mostly traditional Italian with Southwestern, South American and Hungarian influences.

Ownership and Staff are right on Que and understand that the customer is #1 and we are constantly improving our food, system operations, service, menu  and music so you may have the best possible experience at Anthony’s Cafe.

We truly love serving our great customers, It is an honor and a privilege we will continue and never forget.

Thank you for visiting and enjoy your stay with us.